HANDMADE IN SMALL BATCHES • SWEET SHIPPING ACROSS THE U.S.
Cake in the Pye
Half cake. Half pie. Completely irresistible.

The dessert that refuses to choose.

Handcrafted cake-pie hybrids with tender layers, buttery crusts and playful fillings. Made for birthdays, celebrations, or the perfectly ordinary Tuesday.

Shop signature flavorsHow a Pye is made
Baked with joy ✦
Customer favorites

Meet the signature Pyes

Each dessert pairs a soft cake crumb with a crisp pie shell and a generous center. Choose a classic or create a combination of your own.

🍓

Strawberry Celebration

Vanilla cake, berry compote and a cloud of cream.

Bright, fruity & festive
🍫

Midnight Chocolate

Dark cocoa cake, silky ganache and cookie crust.

Deep, rich & fudgy
🍋

Sunshine Lemon

Lemon cake, tangy curd and a buttery golden shell.

Fresh, zesty & smooth
“A little bakery idea that grew into a dessert all its own.”
HandcraftedMixed, filled and finished by hand.
Small BatchThoughtful baking with close attention to texture.
Celebration ReadyDesigned to arrive giftable and joyful.
Build Your OwnPair your favorite cake, crust and filling.
Good to know

Pye questions, answered

What is a Pye?

A layered hybrid that brings cake and pie together in one handcrafted dessert.

How should it be served?

Let chilled Pye rest briefly, then slice with a warm, clean knife.

Can I customize one?

Yes—select flavors and celebration details through the build-your-own experience.